A working test-kitchen ledger of ten thousand recipes.
American Comfort · Soup

Maple and mustard Mushroom Soup

Weeknight-friendly Mushroom Soup with the maple and mustard we come back to again and again. Big flavour, short shopping list.

4.7 from 1,347 cooks
Prep10 min
Cook60 min
Serves4
LevelMedium
Free to cook
Maple and mustard Mushroom Soup
Method

How to cook it

Prep everything first: chop the aromatics, measure the maple and mustard elements, and pat the mushroom dry so it colours well.

Warm the olive oil in a large pan over a medium heat and soften the onion and garlic until sweet and translucent, about 5 minutes.

Add the mixed mushrooms and smoke until it takes on colour and the edges catch, 4 to 6 minutes.

Stir in the buttermilk and the rest of the maple and mustard flavours, letting them cook out for a minute until fragrant.

Add the peas along with a splash of stock or water, then cover and cook gently until everything is tender and the sauce clings.

Taste and adjust the seasoning with salt, pepper and a little acid. It should taste bright, savoury and balanced.

Finish with the chopped thyme and serve while hot.

Tested in the Stewart & Musell kitchen. Timings assume a standard home oven and hob.

More from American Comfort

You might also cook

Cauliflower Cookies in smoked paprika American Comfort Members
American Comfort

Cauliflower Cookies in smoked paprika

The kind of American Comfort plate you make on repeat. smoked paprika, a proper braise, and a...

2 hr 10 min · Medium
American Comfort Black Bean Mash American Comfort Members
American Comfort

American Comfort Black Bean Mash

The kind of American Comfort plate you make on repeat. buttermilk and herb, a proper char, and...

55 min · Easy
Braised Paneer Ramen American Comfort
American Comfort

Braised Paneer Ramen

The kind of American Comfort plate you make on repeat. smoked paprika, a proper braise, and a...

1 hr 45 min · Medium